I. We him? audited the Financial starements of HW3. limited ("the Company"], which comprise the halaltce ahui( ai it March 31, Z024-. and tile Slatrtneht <3J J'roIlL acid Loss, statement 0/ churwci inequity and the statement d I'cash Hows tor the year then ended, and mates to the financial statements., int Indinp a summary u! significant sceutmt111 g pulides mid other esptjn Story information
in our opinion anti to the hestoi our mtormatioii and acrordinp to the explanations Riven to us, extept tr>r tlie effects ni' the matter described in the fliraS for Qualified F>/jfrtfoFt aectimi of our report, the aforesaid financial statements pivc a true and lair view in Conformity with the aecuundnp principles ge 1 ie rally attested Lti [ ndla. of the stale of a fairs of t he Cun ij ia ny as tit Match a 1st, j! »'£ 4, and Its loss, eflitngtf in equity and its cash Ifotvs lor the year ended 011 that dates
IJ. fails for iju.iii fU'd Qplnion
il Treatments of gratuity arid leave atlary are not In conformity with iND-fifi lL> ittipacis thereof .art not readily ascertainable. (Krfer Note No 3 (24|
: Dcptecialluu on comp mien Ls as laid dtuvn In foot BAIt - \ Schedule It of Companies Act, 2013 for hnplenss’ntjTinn from financial results of 31" March, 201b has not been accounted for [Refer Note No. 3 I it" |
III. Key Audit Maders
KeV a udit mailers a re those mailers Lti at. In uu r prole ss i u nal | u d riii etil. were u f most sign! fltanct I il uttr audit u.l the financial statements of the current period. These matters iverc addressed In the context ul our audit of die financial statements as a whole, and in forth lug onr opinion thereon, and we do not provide a separate opinion mi ihese matters, hi addition to the matter tie Serf bed In (he fftr.sr.s for QuaUfisiQpinfdHsection we hove determined the mutters desittbe below:
St.Mo.
|
Key Audit Manet
|
Hnw our audit addressed die key audit matters
|
T
|
The accounts of the company have
|
Phncljpar Audit Procedures urns aro unab'u lb cammwrtt
|
|
been drawn up on going Concern
|
*n etfortt of s4'i,5fr7?arrJi ihsf may he rre»tSrfn(od agiirfif
|
|
atilamptlsci nolwlfh stand ms
|
ants JisM.risa or ma comparty if company fia#ei to
|
|
continuous era son of ref worth and
|
continue as a going concern fa tiering adverse
|
|
suspension of work in the fluctuate
|
predicament
|
|
over a number of period
|
|
2.
|
Lltigtilions end claims -provisions and contingent liabilities
As disclosed ih Notes retailing contingent liability ard provision for tortlinsevKie* Ihe company is involve in direct indirect 1ax and other lliigaiiont (lnigifoiii't ihat se» pending with different statutory
aufogfltie* Whother a liability is
recognized or d-s closed as a contingent liability in the financial statemtnlt s kihif*plly jutfgme-nta and dependent cm a number of significant assumption* ana assessments. The amounts involved arc potentially significant aits deienmining 1tie amount, if any, to he recognized or disclosed n the financial statements. 15 mherenlty sub|ecfive
|
Out Hoy pioecthirat included (ho following:
Ý Assessed the appropriates of the company accounting polic.es, including those relating to provision arei contingent liability by comparing with the applicatte accounting standards;
Assessed the ccmpary process for identification of He pending litigations end completeness tor financial fepoding and aiso for monitoring of signilicanl developments in reaton to such pend ng legations
Ý -Engaged subject matter specialists lo gam an understanding of 1he current status of litigations and monitored changes in ihe disputes ir any. through (iscussions with the management and by reading external advice received by the company where relavanl. to establish thai ihe provisions had been appropriately recogn.zed or disclosed as reqLned.
. Assessed the company assumptions and estmates In respect of litigatons, including the tiabilit.es or provisions recognized or contingent liabilities disclosed m foe financial statements. This involved assessing the probability of an unfavorable Ouitcomr of a given proceeding and ihe reliability of estimates of re ated amounts
Ý Performed- substantive procedures on the underlying calculations SUppOrtn^ the provisions recarded' Assessed 1tie management's ccntSusians through understanding precedents set h similar cases' end COnsKlorug the nppropi intones* or (ho company's description of foe disclosures related to litigations and Whtthc foeic adequaicly preterit *d m Ihe Stand a see firancia. statements
|
3
|
A number of claims tciaiyg Ra.f.26 eram
aDDUj.nolo'y hat bom Indgfcl by Inr
company aga "51 BSNL an various 'sows. (Refer ryote No 3(201
|
. Necessary papers rncluding the order of honourabe
Sup'VTie Court hav* Soar, v-r.rf.fd by L4 VI ondor 1u s-r.v.ns
theooTTK-lnessof aooowimj ef lha sad claim.
|
IV Information i»th£f thati I hr ImuhtNil Stile mi; n I * *nd Auditor's lirport thrrt: Oil;
The Company's Soard of [Hhtctai1* ts responsible for prepti ration of ih<‘ olheriflftttfttAtlon. file
other information comprises the information includedin the Management discussion and Analysis, lin-ant's Bflpori Including Annexures &. Board's rijqjcrtsnd Sh.ires holder's Informsnon. Inn does not Include Llis flirtation!] Statements and .’Liditois' report there nn, fJttr opinion on the financial Statements does nut Cover the ocher tBfomaation anil We dtr no1 express any lumi of assurance conclusion thereon.
In connection with our audit of financial statements, our responsibility is to read the information
dnd. In (loins so# consider whether the other Information Is ttntrerlully I non distent with the
financial statements or our knowledge obtained during the course ot our audit, or otherwise
appears to lie materially misstated.
If, based on the work we have performed, we conclude that there is material misstatement of this other Information, we were required to Eiopoil thatlactWr haw nothing to Report in this regard.
V. Management's Responsibility tor Lhc Stand a Lone Financial Statement*
The Company5 Board of Directors is responsible tor the matters stated in section 13 (5) of the Companies Act, 2013 ("the Act"} with respect to the preparation of these financial statements that give a true and fair vLew of the financial position, finandal performance, changes in equity and rash flows of the Company in accordance with the IND-AS and other accounting principles generally accepted in India, Including the accounting Standards specified under section 133 of the Act. The respective hoard of Directors of flic companies ate also responsible for maintenance adequate accounting records in accordance With the provisions of the Act for safeguarding of the assets of the Company and for preventing and detecting frauds and other irregularities: selection and
application of appropriate accounting policies; making judgments and estimates that are reasonable and prudent: and design, implementation and maintenance of adequate ijdeni.il financial controls, that were operating effectively for ensuring the accuracy and completeness of
the accounting records, relevant to the preparation and presentation of the finandal statement that
give a true and fair view and are free from material Is statement, whether due to fraud or error.
In preparing the financial statements, Ftosrd of Directors of the company is responsible fur assessing the Company's ability In continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters
related to goi ng concern and using the going con cem basis of accou nting uti less nna n agement eith er Intends to liquidate the Company or to cease operations, or has o realistic alternative but to do so.
The Board of Directors Is also responsible for overseeing tbe Company's financial reporting process.
VI, Audi tor’s Elf s pn ns ibl li ties for t he Audit of the Filta neial Statements
Our objectives are L« obLain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are /tee from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to Issue an auditor's
report that includes our opinion. Reason a hlr assurance is a high Irvcl of assurance, hut is not a
guarantee that an audit conducted In accordance with SAs will always detect a material Ýmisstatement when it exists. Misstatements. Kin arise from Fraud or error and are considered material if. individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions of users taken or the basis of the financial statements-
As part ot an auditing accordance with SAs ,wc citcmse professional judgment and maintain
prufesSl unali keep frit Iciiffl (li rough 0 ill lltc an di LWe HI So;
Ý Identify and assess UitL risks nfmaterial missiaienienl oi the 1 manual statements, whether due lit fraud nr error, design and perform audit procedures responsive to those nsks, and obtain nudlt evidence that Is sufficient and appropriate tn provide a hasis (or our opinion. The risk ol not detecting a material misstatenifnt resulting trniu fraud is hipticr lhan tor oik resulting Irntn error, as Iraud may Involve collusiujp forgery Intentional omissions, tidsrep regents tlfihiS, or Ike override of Internal control.
Ý Obtain tin uMerslitidltig of Internal control relevant to the audit in order in design Audit procedures that arc appropriate in the clrcuiu.sttnces. Under section 143(31(1] of the Companies Act, 2013, we are also responsible for expressing our opinion an whether the company' has adeguate Internal fm BEirid IcuntrolsSy sleuii npl accaudl I ieu peral In gell L'cttvenessol's ud wort! ru I s
Ý Evaluate Ihe appropriateness ul accounting policies used and I he reasonableness of accounting estimates and related disclosures tnAdeby management.
* Cdnflmle on the appropriateness at management's use of the going concern basis Ol' accounting alid. based on the audit evidence obtained, whether a material uncertainty exists related In even Li or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the Company's ability to continue us ,i going concent. If we conclude that a material uncertainty exists, ive are required (o draw attention in
our autlltor's report lo the related disclosures In the financial statements or, if such disclosures are IrtatleijLiAte, to mod lljjt OUT npliliOIL Our runehlsiuns ate based Ý m tin.'audit evlilelufe uhtallied up to the date of our auditor's report, itowever. future events or conditions may cause the Company to cease to continue as a going concern.
Ý Materiality Is the magnitude of misstatements In ihe financial Statements that, individually or tti
uggreijate', makes iL probable'that the economic decisions of ,i reasonably knowledgeable useroftlie Financial Statements may he influenced. We eoneider quantitative materiality and qualitative factors in (t) pljnning die scope ul our .juilil work end in evaluating the rcsidts ol our work; and (iij
to evaluate the effect of any identified misstatements hi the Financial Sts tsnients.
Ý Evaluate the overall presentation, strucmri? and content ot the tinancial statements, including the disclosures, and whether ihe tin mid u! statements represent the underlying traneaeflmwsid eveids in a manner that achieve* fair presentation.
- Obtain siithcicnt appmpriate audit evidence rr-g.u ifing the financial information of The entities nr business activities within the company to express an opinion on I he linanciiil statements. Wt arc responsible For the direction, supervision and performimre of the -mrlit of Fnumcfal statements of such entities Included in financial statements.
Ý We communicate with thosE charged with govErnance regarding among other matters, the planned scope and timing of the atn£t and significant audit findings, including otiy significant deficiencies m Internal control that we Identify dim ng our and It.
- We also provide those charged with governance with a statement that wo have complied with relevant rlliitiil requirements regarding Independence, and to cutnnuihlcate With them all relationships and other matter, that tnaV reiSDIlkiitybr thought to hear oil oLLr independence, alnl where applicable, related safeguards,
* From the matters eomttm incited with those charged with governance, we determine those matters
that were ol must significance Ln the audit of the financial s'a'omen Is ol the Lum.rl period and arc therefore the key audit matters. We describe these matters in our auditor's report unless law or regulation precludes public disclosure about the matter or When. In extremely rare CireutriS till res. we determine that a matter should not be communicated in our report because the adverse constt|ucnccs of doing so would rcasonably he expected to outweigh llic public interest benefits of such cumniti ideation.
ViI. Reporton Other E.cgal and Regulatory Requirements
I As reo|Hired hylhc Companies [Auditor's Report! Order, IQZQ ['the Order'"I. issued by the Central tlovernment nf India m terms oFsnh-section [flj of section HU of the Companies Act 2013, wo give |p the Anre^une -2 statement nn the matters specified In paragraphs 3 and 4 of the Order, to the men t applicable.
3 As required by Section H3[3] of the Act. weTe port that:
(a) We have sought and nil brined all the information and explanations which to tile best of our knowledge and hr-liei wv are neces-saiy (or the purposes ol nur audit of the aforesaid financial statements.
f/tji III nur opinion, proper Imoks of account ns required ly law have been kept by the Company so far ns It appears frtan our em ml nation orthos* books,
(c| Ttic Balance Sheet, the Statement ot Profit and L.uss, tile SlaLumeut ut changes in liquifies and the Cash Flow' Statement ilealt With by tills Kcporl arc in agreement with the bouts ul account nialntalncd for the purpose of preparation of the financial statements.
{til In our opinion, die aforesaid financial statements comply with tlie IN ft AS specified wirier Section 133 of the Act, read with Rule l of the Companies (Accounts) Rule 5,20 E 4.
(c) On Llie basis of [he Written representations received from llie directors as cm Hist March. Z02-1, taken on record by the Board nf Pi rectors, none of the directors is disqualified on Ma rch. 31 Ý'. 202-1 r I rum hemp appointed as a directors in terms of section JA4 (Li) uttbc AcL
(f) With respect to tiie itrteqn<icy of the interna! Finniiaul controls over financial reporting ofrlie
Company and llie operating elfecLivoncss of such coEilrols, refer lu our separate hteporl in
'Atmexure -1.
|g) Wi& respect te thee thefjiiHJttq&i to be included in Auditor's Report in arcordanre with the net]Liiremcnts of Section 197( 1 ft} of llie Act, as amended :
tit on r oplnion and to file best of o u r 11 ifu r nu tie ti and accordl ug to expl muiticm s given to us, the reimmerado-n paid by the Company to it's directors during the year is in accordance wtth the p rov Islons of section 197 of tf ir Art.
It} With respect to the other matters to be Included In the Auditor's Report in accordance with Rule 11 of the Companies (Audit and Auditors) Rules, 2014, in our opinion and to the host of mi r itifn I'm a tion mid aonordl ng to the explanations given ro tisr
i. Tlie tfomptirvy has disclosed the Impact of pending litigations on Its financial position In ILs financial statements-Refer Mule ft (2If) to die financial statements,
il. The (fumpany docs not has any material foreseeable loss arising out of derivative contract
Hi. There lias heen no delay In transferring amounts, required lo he transferred,, to tlie Investor Education and Protection Pimd by the Company.
iV.fa) The management has represented lhat, the best nf its knnwiedge end beliet, no funds have been advanced or Loaned or invested (either burrowed Funds lit share premium nr any Other sounres nr kind of funds) hy the company or in any other persons nr entities Including foreign entitles [Intermediaries) with die understanding, whether recorded In writing or otherwise, that the intermediary shall, directly or indirect Jy lend or Invest hi o tiler persons or villi Lies identified In any manner whatsoever ("ultimate Beneficiaries') hy or mi belial! td the company or provide any guarantee. security ortho like on behalf ot the ultimotp Beneficiaries,
(h) The mgniijDDHil li.is represented th.it , tn the beet of its hnosviotlpc and belief, no hinds lTive been received bgi the company front tiny person or i-iHiTint. including
foreign entities ("Fundingentities"] willi the Understanding whether recorded in
writing or olherwlso. that die company shall directly or indirectly. Lend or invest in Other persons or entitles identified in jelv rninner rthumeW | "ultima tr bettefidarfes"] hv or on hehaif of thi- funding parties nr provide any guarantee, scruritv or Like on behalf Gt the ultimate beneficiaries.
|ej tliisrd on llie procedures prrJonncd that Ltavc been considered reason,ibic and appropriate in the circumstances, nothing has com to our notice tint has Ýcaused US tn bcJtevc that the representations under sub-clause (Li) and fiii) dFRuIc ti(a| contain anv materlil misstatement,
v. In view of iwcumuJated loss Company did not declare and paid dividend during the
Current year and also m the prtvbout year
vl. Tiie Company mill mains its accounts manually hence qutatfcn of hmdng accounting softwsrt foriuullttrailideiitlfltution under rule 1] (9)does notarise
(i, BA&& COMPANY CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS R . NO. - 30 117 LE
PARTNER fO.GUHAJ (M . Pill -05470?)
IIJHN: 24054702BKEEME»7‘>
Place: Kotkot.i
nnte:2ii1h May2024,
|